Do you ever have those "stop the world, I'm getting off" moments? Reading the press release for this book gave me several of those. For example:
- Walmart introduced an anti-aging make-up line for 8-12 year olds
- JCPenney released a T-shirt that read "I'm too pretty to do homework so my brother has to do it for me"
- Disney Princess products generated $4 billion in 2009 (it was a mere $300 million in 2000).
This is what the publicity for the book says:
"More and more, parents are deluged with products that teach their girls that the sexes are fundamentally different, that the most important thing for girls is to be pretty (and later "hot"), and that "girl power" is expressed by having the most stuff... The pursuit of physical perfection has been recast as the source of female empowerment, and commercialization has spread the message faster and farther, reaching girls at ever-younger ages... The potential negative impact of this new girlie-girl culture is undeniable."
I loved the book. It's easy to read, funny, judgmental where it needs to be and non-judgmental when it comes to the everyday struggles of individual parents. It's sensible and is the kind of thing that gives feminism a good name. I loved the stories of where Peggy Orenstein went, in the name of research (a toddler beauty pageant, a Miley Cyrus concert, the American Girl store). I tell you, if she lived next door, I'd be round there for a cup of tea every other day. I love a good story. In fact, I think I'm going to buy the house next door and have her move in.
I did meet her a few weeks ago actually (so on the basis of that, she would probably be totally up for the moving-in-next-door idea). She came from classy California to our little flyover state to give a talk, promoted by the Girl Scouts, who, incidentally, are much more fabulous than I gave them credit for. Turns out they are all about building girls' courage, confidence and character, and have an advocacy program dealing with all these kinds of important concerns.
I know, I know. Lots of you are sitting there thinking "Iota. There are more important issues out there. Don't get your knickers in a twist." (I just have to throw in that expression, because (a) American readers love British expressions like that and (b) I miss using it in everyday speech.) But it's an issue I feel strongly about. And pretty much everything I feel about it is in Cinderella Ate My Daughter.
I have three copies to give away. Thank you Harper Collins. You can enter simply by leaving a comment, by the end of Tuesday, March 13th. I will pick three winners using a random number generator. Please don't think that if you have sons and not daughters, that this book isn't for you. It is. Your son's way of looking at women is as prone to manipulation as your daughter's way of being one. If you don't have children, it's just a darn good read.
By the way, if you're an American living in Britain and you win, you can request an inexpensive mailable item (Cheezits, Rice-a-Roni, a double-ended Sharpie - whatever it is you're jonesing after), and I'll pop it in the parcel with the book. Provided you write "knickers in a twist" in the comments. Come on. Cross that cultural divide.
Just this morning I was thinking again about the fact that I am raising a daughter and about what this means. I hope I win a copy but otherwise it sounds like I'll have to buy one because it's too good to miss.
ReplyDeleteThis, as you well know, is a topic, I regularly 'campaign' about. As a girl guide leader we are about promoting self esteem generated without a mirror. Thank you for highlighting it and it is so worth twisting knickers over. These girls whose minds are being warped are our future.
ReplyDeleteI worked a lot with guide and brownie groups back when I was a librarian in the UK. I was impressed with how they've progressed over the years. I was a cub as a kid, but never really liked it much.
ReplyDeleteI remember reading about this book ages ago in the New York Times and thinking it sounded brilliant. Yes, I don't have boys, but every morning when I see all the little girls in pink waiting at the schoolbus stop these issues cross my mind.
ReplyDeleteWell now I have my knickers in a twist over the fact that I live in Russia and the chances HC are interested in sending me a book - even if I DID win - are pretty slim. Oh well. Toot toot, pip pip, am off to eat my crustless cucumber sandwiches for an early afternoon tea...
ReplyDeleteHmm, being a liberated woman, I am obviously not wearing any knickers to get in a twist. But leaving that aside, this book sounds great & something I am suddenly having to deal with mch more having moved back to the UK from a crosscultural/international developing world sphere where there weren't many shops or big malls, we didn't watch tv, just dvds, the school, church & community were full of so many different nationalities, ethnicities & cultural backgrounds that even in this world of mass communication & social media there really wasn't a norm of cool brands, with-it trends & homogenous dressing & hair styling. & now suddenly I am face dwith Life In The UK. Agh! A tool to deal with this wd be very useful. In fact I'd be tickled pink at finding a solution to this pickle I'm in!
ReplyDeleteI've heard all about this book too. Please enter me. I'd love to read it!
ReplyDeleteOo, yes, please can you stick my name in the draw? I've only a little boy to avoid gender stereotyping with at the moment, but it still really matters to me.
ReplyDeleteOoooh!! KNICKERS IN A TWIST!! I love that phrase. Any excuse to use it is a good one ;) I haven't heard of the book but it sounds really interesting. Love this post, Iota. It's really got me thinking. I loved being a girl scout, by the way :D
ReplyDeleteI'd love to read it. And have a queue of people who'd be reading it after me. I shall print off appropriate bits and stick them to the fridge for my boys to read when they are fridge raiding. It is a major parental aim of mine, my boys will treat women properly. And put their own clothes in the laundry basket.
ReplyDeleteSo far my 12 year old is doing pretty well - gets very excited about signing up for science and engineering workshops and, although she has some makeup, she hasn't worn any in weeks which makes me happy. Still, I'd love a copy of the book.
ReplyDeleteHave started to write 2 long replies to this and lost both...I hate comments pages - this is always happening. So you will have to guess my comments.
ReplyDeleteLove
Josephine xxx
I get my knickers in a twist the way I see this lived out by Ukrainian girls and women. I'd love to read this book and have something rational to see in response to what I see and the conversations I have with women here. And I would love to be able to use the expression 'don't get your knickers in a twist' in everyday speech, but 1. it would sound strange coming from my American mouth and 2. no one would understand me. I'm gonna be in the US next month, so I might have to add it to my reading list for the short time I'm there. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteI would love a copy! No kids, but have a lot of interactions with them...
ReplyDeleteOoh! I remember your original post about this and thought: "I must read that".
ReplyDeleteSince then, of course, the girls have all started coming out with phrases such as "We can't do that, Mummy, that's a boys' thing". Not, fortunately about lego, but still.
So please... please. Random number generator gods. Pick me!
Sounds like a must read - I have become so aware of gender stereotyping since becoming a mum. Fingers crossed!
ReplyDeleteThis book is v. interesting, read it a while ago although depressing how things just get worse and worse, not better and better. I have a child of each gender and interestingly my son is much firmer in his views about 'girl' toys and 'boy' toys and colours although until he was 4 or so he loved pink and wore dresses. His 7 year old sister has been consistently uninterested in pink/princesses/dolls/things marketed to girls, but that is partly, I believe, because she has a killjoy feminist mother who is always harping on at her and also because we have no TV, no magazines and very limited exposure to other media in our lives. I believe my boy's view gender division is partly influenced by his preschool who buy into that crap.
ReplyDelete