Friday, October 1, 2010

More book recommendations

What a fabulous idea for a sequel to Monsieur Saguette and his Baguette from Not waving but ironing (whose blog title reminds me of my own former moniker). Mrs Ruffins and her Wholemeal Muffins. I love it. I can picture her now, a cheerful, homely, English lady, who has as many imaginative uses for her muffins as Monsieur Saguette does for his baguette. She will go on holiday to France, where she will meet and fall in love with the man and his impressive French stick, and marry him. They will live happily ever after, or whatever the French equivalent is. They’ll have children: Mademoiselle Ciabatta, and her brother, le petit Roland, known as Cinnamon Rol. They’ll have two dogs called Crumpet and Scone, and a cat called Sourdough Puss.

I didn’t warn you, by the way, when I was recommending Monsieur Saguette and his Baguette, not to get the book if you are the kind of parent who balks at explaining to their child what an armed robber is, or how it can be ok, in a work of fiction, to eat bread that has been utilised to effect an escape from the city sewers, via a manhole.

But while we’re on the subject of books, people often ask me “Iota, do you know of any books for small children which have positive role models for girls?” Actually, they don’t… but they should, because it just so happens I do. Such books are few and far between, when you think about the volume of printed media about princesses who waft around waiting for their prince to come, managing only to kiss a few frogs or kow-tow to a few evil relations in the meanwhile. Here are two, which I recommend heartily, if you’re the kind of mother who likes to swim against the pink and sparkly tide every now and again.

The book Princess Grace, by Mary Hoffman is great. It's a very thoughtful treatment of the whole issue. Grace is excited when she learns her class are to be in a parade, and she can dress up as a princess. With the teacher's help, the class starts researching princesses, and what it is that a princess actually does. There's a great line where Grace decides that sitting around in a pink floaty dress sounds very boring, and that she’d rather be the kind of princess who leads a bold and adventurous life. I always want to cheer at that point. I would recommend the book for age 4 and up.

The other book on this subject that I like is Princess Pigtoria and the Pea, by Pamela Duncan Edwards. The story starts in the traditional way, but [spoiler alert] in the morning, Pigtoria is so cross with the pig prince for putting a pea under her mattress, that she goes off with the pizza delivery pig instead. It’s funny, and the text is wittily full of words beginning with the letter ‘P’. “Panting, Pigtoria plunked onto her pillows”, for example. This is a book that a 2 year old could enjoy, but 6-yo still reads and likes it.

And if you want a film with a positive female lead, there’s always Shrek. Three cheers for Fiona, I say.

8 comments:

  1. Roald Dahl's Cinderella, (in Revolting Rhymes)decided that the prince was really pretty awful so she married a 'simple jam maker by trade' and lived happily ever after.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Of course I love the Little House books, though they were from a time long ago, ignore the slightly racist bits and it makes interesting historical reading.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like the sound of Pigtoria.

    I agree with Susanna, the Little House books have a really strong heroine (Laura) who likes to do all kinds of tomboyish things. And, in the same vein, Little Women.

    Another great book I enjoyed as a child was Harriet the Spy - a good tale for budding writers!

    ReplyDelete
  4. yes I was going to say Roald Dahl's Cinderella. My husband (for soem reason....) loves the line "she whipped a pistol from her knickers.") There are a load of 'alternative' fairy tales out there. I used to d a scheme of work with yr 7 on stereotypes & these alternative tales which they always loved.

    ReplyDelete
  5. We like 'fancy nancy". It's her vocabulary that is fancy, not just her outfits.

    ReplyDelete
  6. One of my 7-year-old Daughter's favorite books is by Jane Yolen and Heidi E.Y. Stemple and it is called "Not All Princesses Dress In Pink." It is an outstanding book stating that while some princesses are prissy, others like to play sports, get dirty, climb trees, etc. (yet always with a sparkly crown), and it doesn't make them any less of a girl. Perfect for my daughter, who insists on wearing dresses, jewerly and fingernail polish whilst climbing trees and collecting worms!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Well, thank you for the link, Ms Iota! I am very flattered. And I shall definitely check out some of the books mentioned here. They seem to be rather thin on the ground here in Blighty and I resort to tutting a lot while reading Cinderella (ugly sisters - hah! That always brings on a lecture. 'Sometimes people who are beautiful outside, are ugly inside..' 'Can you just read it, Mummy?').

    ReplyDelete