Saturday, October 16, 2010

I am sad

I am sad. I am sad and weary. I am sad and weary and I have a question.

Those of you who have followed this blog for a while will know that Husband and I have been trying to return to the UK for, oh, two years or so, this move being dependent on Husband finding employment. One of the bad things about being a stay at home mum is that you find yourself in a position to contribute little to the mix, and entirely dependent on the whims and vagaries of the field of work of your spouse (in Husband's case, a very narrow field). The job search coincided with the credit crunch and its aftermath, and though Husband's area of employment isn't exactly at the sharp end of the business world, and perhaps a little cushioned from other people's harsher realities, no doubt the timing hasn't exactly helped.

I am sad, because we have just had disappointing news of the latest application, and weary, because this feels like boringly familiar territory. Husband has been doing all the right things. His cv ticks all the boxes. He knows how to present it. He has spent time networking with people in the field. He keeps in touch. We do not wallow in what Americans call 'a pity party' each time he is unsuccessful, but get right back up, and look for the next opportunity. He is not picky.

Here is my question, though. Is recruitment in other people's fields quite as bruising an experience as it has been for us - or have we been particularly unlucky? I can't help thinking that in most businesses, the process goes something like this: the job is advertised, a shortlist is drawn up, candidates are interviewed, one is appointed, and the others told they've been unsuccessful. In Husband's two areas of potential employment (universities, and the church - or church-related organisations), the process seems more like entering a maze. It is very common for no candidate to be appointed, and the post re-advertised in a slightly different format a few weeks or months later. It is very common for the process to take months. It is very common for the process to take months, and then to be abandoned. It is very common for them not to bother to tell candidates what has happened. It is very common for the whole thing to be a cover for the appointment of an internal candidate. With crashing irony, the time when Husband was in that situation, and all his department had to do was appoint him to carry on with his research, for which they had received money from the government ear-marked for that purpose and for him specifically by name, they managed to appoint someone else instead, who had no relevant experience at all. The words 'piss-up' and 'brewery' come to mind. It's how we ended up in America.

Is the business world more efficient? I suppose committees of philosophy and/or theology academics were never going to be the speediest and most efficient of decision-making bodies, were they? I picture them all in a room, trying to discuss the relative merits of the candidates, stuck in the mire of theoretical considerations, and going off on tangents from which they have no hope of ever returning.

As for the church, well, I can only despair. Husband has been on the receiving end of the kind of behaviour from senior church men and women, on both sides of the Atlantic, that would make the Pharisees blush. If there isn't a Parable of the Blushing Pharisee, there jolly well ought to be. The inefficiency, the waste of money and time, the in-fighting, the empty promises... Most of all, the sheer lack of consideration. Do these people not realise what kind of effort goes into a job application? And the time it takes? Blimey, if Husband was paid by the hour for job applications and their accompanying preparation, he wouldn't even be looking for a new position, we'd be so wealthy. Do they not realise the emotional energy that is expended? Over literally months? Do they not think what it is like to consider moving a family? Because with every clergy job (not just in our case), it's not only the job that's involved. It's the location, the house, the schools, the whole life? Don't they think about that at all?

It is with this in mind that I am SO tempted to drop in the name of the latest Bishop who has just changed his mind on a job. This job was advertised in April, and then again in September, after a failed first round. Flight tickets had been purchased for Husband's interview. He wasn't guaranteed the job - I get that. So I know that it was a risky business getting excited about the place, and researching what it might be like to live there. No, he hadn't been promised the job, but he HAD been promised an interview. At a week's notice of the flight, he received an email saying the Bishop had decided nor to go ahead with the post at the present time. At least they are refunding the flight ticket (they'd asked us to pay half). And now Husband has to go away and hide somewhere for a week, because of course he'd told people he was going away, and has arranged for classes to be taken in his absence. It wouldn't do for him to bump into students in Dillons.

I realise that this all sounds horribly petty, and of course I don't know the inside story. I don't know what pressures other people are operating under, and I don't know what frustrations and problems they face. But for heaven's sake, STOP promising more than you can deliver. Stop it. Just STOP IT.

Oh, and the reason I'm so very tempted to name that Bishop is this. I know he, or one of his communications staff, will have his name on google alert. I just know it. And I want him to realise that this is a big deal. That for him, what is just a little twist in some Diocesan politics, or an unfortunate mistake, or an embarrassing glitch, for us, is life-changing. I want him to know, because once people get to a certain level in an organisation, they forget what it's like to be nearer the bottom of the pile, and they have people around them who shield them from the memory. They don't even have the decency to write emails themselves (too busy, too important). But of course I won't name and shame, because we can't afford to be alienating people in such a small world. A small sucky world.

Back to my question. Is our experience typical? Is recruitment in every sector such a painful process? Or is Husband just in the wrong business?

I should really retitle this post. I am sad. I am sad and weary. Most of all, I am sad and weary and ANGRY.

25 comments:

  1. Iota, I sympathise, truly I do.
    But... does he want to work for somebody who changes things like this, on a whim? Or an organisation so unprofessional?

    Obviously, unless you find someone who will pay by the hour for job application prep etc, he has to work for somebody,
    but my experience of these organisations is that they make up their own rules, and suit themselves always. Universities may be a little better, I don't know.
    Power corrupts.
    And I agree with you that when these people get to a certain level, they forget what it's like to be an ordinary person, with responsibilities.
    You've every right to be angry.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That is so annoying! Glad your husband got his fair back though.
    I think sometimes these jobs are filled before they get advertised. Not a good time to be looking for work over here in this present clime.

    Maggie X

    Nuts in May

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am so out of the job's market now I am not sure, but I do thik this sounds worse than a lot of the experiances MadDad and I have been through. You have every right to be sad and angry. Rant away

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Iota. It's a bit personal and not my story to tell, but my father has been in the same situation for a full year -- riding on top of a brief employment for which he and my mother moved 200 miles -- only to be "let go" with a major layoff 6 months later. It made me want to strangle the jerks that brought them so far away from their family and friends! Not to mention the horrible effect its had on my father. So I guess what I'm saying is that even in the corporate world, the US is truly suffering, and people like you and your husband (and my parents) along with it. I think companies and organisations are struggling, too, with budgets that change daily and so much uncertainty in the annual plan -- that a decision to hire someone one day might be very different from the next. It stinks and feels like people are being "jerked around" but I'd bet that the people doing the "jerking around" probably recognise it and feel bad, too. This economy has everyone strapped over a barrel. TheMadHouse is right, though, when she says rant away. It really stinks. You are not alone - and there is light at the end of the tunnel.

    ReplyDelete
  5. God. I would be furious too. I want to swear (on your behalf), but best not, I suppose. x

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well I am swearing a very lot - not least cos we'd far rather you were on this side of the pond than that (sorry America an' all that.) But that is a repeated and truly awful way of treating people, whatever situation they or the organisation is in. I hate that whole thing that you so have the lower (?) hand (or whatever is the opposite of upper hand) when you are job hunting, and yet once you get there is it JUST A JOB! Gaah, for you, lovely Husband, and the little Quota-lets. Not to mention ageing grandparents and mates who'd like to see you more than every couple of years.

    Grrissimo.
    xxx

    Love Josephine

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nothing out of the ordinary in these times...so many places are looking for an employee who can do ALL things at ALL times. I just read that people who lost their jobs during this recession will never get them back because they are now underqualified. The workplace went on without them, getting someone to do their work and other work, too. So, now the employer wants ONE person to do a myriad of tasks.

    Also, once the job opens, other things could occur within the business, or church, that make the employer reconsider hiring, such as a downturn in income.

    Life as we once knew it is NO MORE. There is a new economy and a new way of doing business, and that is everywhere, and all of us must reconsider our place. I just heard Suze Orman say, "the rich are getting richer, and the poor are getting poorer, and this is not going to change for any time soon."

    ReplyDelete
  8. How frustrating for you, it's not fair you should be treated this way at all. There should be firmer rules for the recruitment process, after all a job application means so much to the person applying and shouldn't be subject to the vagaries of the person recruiting. The private sector usually works a bit more smoothly but still has its hiccups I think. In the past I've not heard how I've done on interviews until over a month later or I've been told that they've changed their mind about what they want the job to be. Naming and shaming would be satisfying but probably wouldn't help the situation. Wishing you and your husband the very best of luck in finding the right job. I don't know exactly waht he does, but is there a slightly different role or sector he could go for?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Dear lovely Iota, Like others I'm afraid I don't know if this is just what it's like - I'm out of the market, and B is sticking tight to the job he has... but I do know it took him months to find a job the last time he was looking, and that wasn't in a recession, and I do know that he got mucked around, and messed around and told ridiculous things as reasons for not taking applications forward, things that made it very clear that they hadn't read his cv, or hadn't understood it, or just couldn't be bothered. So, while I think your experience is worse than most, I also think that your sad conclusion is also right, that some people just forget what it's like for us at or near the bottom of the ladder.

    I suppose though that you just, as you say, have to pick yourselves up, and have to keep believing that the right job is out there and you and he will find it.

    In the meantime, please keep ranting. And we will all keep our ears to the ground for fantastic churchy/academicky jobs, because you never know...

    ReplyDelete
  10. I sympathise with your frustrations: they were mine 3 years ago. My husband went on interview after interview for ages until he finally got this latest uni. job, and now he's stuck on endless Hiring Committees. They've had 5 searches and hired 1 person, which to my mind sounds like a complete waste of time and money, but half the time it's all down to a few petty people who think they are way more Intellectual and Important than they really are, so the Hapless Candidate hasn't got a chance unless they are MORE Important and Intellectual (or they know someone). It's enough to make a department party a VERY prickly place to be sometimes. I hope something real (and well paid) comes up in your chosen area soon.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Oh Iota, you will make it home one day, of that I am sure. All of this noise is to give you something to write about on your blog. :D

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think it's more typical of the public sector (including churches) where the eye isn't on profit. In the private sector, there's usually a reason for interviewing people, and if there really is an opening, they need to fill it as quickly as possible. None of this faffing about with whether or not they have a vacancy.
    My sister works in the (medical/educational) public sector in England and they are always being messed around. She has spent the last two years interviewing for places because either her current project funding was being cut (it wasn't, in the end) or the funds had been transferred elsewhere.
    That pissup wasn't happening either. So inefficient.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I'm so sorry to hear it didn't happen - I know you had a lot of hopes invested. Grr and double grr on that Bishop. Who knows what is happening in the UK, though, with all those public sector jobs being cut. Maybe it's not the best time to be back there after all? But I hope it happens for you really soon all the same.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Job hunting is really disheartening. I wonder if it's the current economy. I found the only way I could get in anywhere was by people I knew at the place. It is really frustrating that funding disappears and people back out and are not straight forward. Don't worry, hang in there and your luck will come.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I just wanted to add a little ray of light. I'm not an economist and I don't pretend to be one -- but there is an amazing economics professor here in my programme. He is one of those brilliant minds you come across once, maybe twice in your life. The other day, he set out very compelling data to show who/when this current job situation in the US might end. It is a very long and complicated story, but basically, it is on the way to resolving and he believes it will be fully resolved within 2 years. The point is -- things ARE changing and the economy is a cyclic thing. Things will get better, and if this guy is right, sooner than any of the campaign-trail/soap-box politicians would lead you to believe in this current election season. Sorry to go on and on, but this time last year there were no jobs in my sector, yet this month alone I've been approached by recruiters three times. My field is R&D and tends to receive early funding in these things, but it is a sign of more to come. I truly believe we're headed for better times soon.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Oh that sounds like a horrible experience. I've only had experience of job hunting in academia and schools, so I suppose my experience has been that you're absolutely right and that's exactly how it all goes. I hope his next application is successful.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hi Iota, I hadn't read this before i emailed my response to you, but am glad to hear now they are refunding the fare tho I guess that also means hubby's suggestion of coming for a chat anyway was turned down. As I said I am so very sorry. In asnwer to your question, my husband finds it the same in the NGO sector, takes forever, lots of internal appointments & sometimes it's more informal, with loose or vague promises & changes of direction etc. I agree with Expat if it's not a private org there is a lot of faffing & mind changing & a swith the NGO sector, it also involves movign countries, continents etc it's all big stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I can vouch that it is much the same in the business world.
    There are, I dare say, a plethora of jobs advertised and if you talk to any head hunter (and I do, quite a lot) they are keen to tell you how the market has picked up and is looking better.

    However. ALL my interviews for prospective jobs have come from networking. Former colleagues, clients, friends, recommendations, etc. Even when approached by a head hunter it has been because they heard/knew of me via someone else. I have lost count now of the jobs advertised I have applied for over the past year, but I can tell you one thing: even when the spec is a mirror image of my CV, I inevitably get a 'thanks but no thanks' email back, which just tells me that the whole process is a farce.

    It is a pain and you cannot but persevere. Eventually something will come out of it but you need both a thick, nay, very thick skin and a wealth of patience.

    I have the former and am learning the latter.

    LCM x

    p.s. Linked In - does your husband use this? By far best 'free' tool around for networking professionals

    ReplyDelete
  19. horrendous. how awful to feel so trapped. to be so trapped, i might add. all i can say is that jobs in my field don't even get advertised. it's all by who you know. and these days, that's not very many people. so i also feel trapped. the same is true for my husb, whose job makes him miserable. i know you can't sympathise because you'd rather be trapped where we are, but i can assure you he's not alone. not that that should make you feel any less sad or mad.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Is it typical? No, not in my field or in my husband's, both of which tend to be much more cut-and-dried (ie. you're either in or you're out, which can be brutal and demoralising in its own rather bruising way). So-called 'vocational' jobs though do seem to go this way. It's a similar story in medicine, or at least it is in the UK. You must be feeling so angry, hurt and frustrated, and it must be very difficult to stay sane and rational in order to keep your husband's spirits up. Something I know I'd fail dismally at (Why can't we go back to the UK? WHY are we here, etc etc...). The 'right' job will come, you'll look back and might even laugh at the ludicrous situations you found yourselves in. Until then. rant knowing you have a very sympathetic readership.

    ReplyDelete
  21. hope things turn a corner very soon.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Certainly in the UK universities sector (and really anything reliant on the public purse) absolutely everything is on hold right now. I suspect it's going to be another year or two until people settle down with the new reality and figure out how to move forward.

    And hey, it could be worse. My position is probationary still (final year) and comes up for review AFTER the spending review (i.e. in a few weeks). So guess who is feeling highly expendable and like she should be keeping an eye on the US job market?

    ReplyDelete
  23. I was just talking with a friend recently about how many times we had each applied for jobs, been told we were among the final two or three...then never heard anything again. No phone call, no email. In fact, they dodged emails and phone calls for weeks.

    Companies can be very dysfunctional. It sounds like the church can be even moreso.

    Hope you are staying optimistic.

    ReplyDelete